Sig Ratings

[World Ablaze]

Figured this might be fun to bring back.
Ok, the rules are simple for this, simply rate the sig of the person above you.

[Romeo]

2/5

Screencap.

[ca$hmoney]

8/10 for Tyson Kidd
4/10 for the other because Matt Hardy is fat.

[EB4]

7.5/10 I really like how the name is where the powder used to be.

[Søren]

5/10

Never been a fan of e-feds.

[Rogue]

6/10. It's kind of plain, but I do like the texture.

[Romeo]

6/10. Would've been higher if the text was easier to read.

[Son of Shockey]

8.25/10. Tyson Kidd is cool.

6.5/10. It's an E-Fed champ pic. Not amazingly cool, but not amazingly bad. Plus, ya gotta give props to a guy with a title.

[cﾘnical]

7/10 It's simple in a good way, plus I mark for the name so damn much. There's just nothing especially awesome about the graphic to justify more than a 7. It's solid.

[Zuma]

8.420/10 for the LOP classic.

[Wevv Mang]

Who watches the watchmen?

I do.

7 out of 10.

[Marksman]

7.5/10

Made me Lol when I first saw it but ever since it's made a slight chuckle for me.

[Romeo]

8/10 for Y2J for great picture quality and simplicity of the whole ripple thing.

5/10 for the other one due to the horrible poster edge filtering.

[Box Car Rocco]

9/10 for Tyson kid, I don't know much about effects but that's pretty awesome.

5/10 for e-fed.

[Chewbacca]

9/10

BLINK 182 is amazing. But I want the Christian sig aswell. :D

[Jar Jar Binks]

3/5 im not a big zelda fan

[Chewbacca]

6/10

Just a bit cheesy for my taste but good

[The Godfather]

7/10 - The pics are good but they don't really mesh well

[Jar Jar Binks]

9/10 Coolest Jericho sig ever

[JoeyShinobi]

5/10...you can't really see much of the background pics, and the text doesn't really make much sense (HBK wasn't 'bred' an icon...)

[Jar Jar Binks]

6/10 can't relly see what is hiding inside your letters

[Stinger]

Hiding in Shinobi's letters is the awesome Katie Lea.

Anyway, 5/10. I like the concept, but it just doesn't seem to mesh well.

[Jar Jar Binks]

7/10 h-o-t

[Ziggy]

6/10

It's decent, but like others said, it doesn't mesh well.

[Chewbacca]

6/10
its so basic its sick haha

[Swanton Bomb]

6/10 - The colours are a little dull, but that's just me.

[CoLD]

God damn...way to big and way to much blue.

2 / 10

Sorry

[Romeo]

5/10 - I'm not sure what you're trying to say.

[Swanton Bomb]

8/10 for the Tyson Kidd one. It's brilliant, but it would look better with a black backgound.

[Vikingsno.1fan]

0/10

the only way that would be cool is if it were glacier instead of hardly.

[Ziggy]

7/10

A little big, but otherwise lovely =D

[ca$hmoney]

6.5/10, kinda basic, but nice

[Jar Jar Binks]

8/10 Very good and it looks cool

[Romeo]

It's brilliant, but it would look better with a black backgound.

Begging your pardon?

What theme are you using for the forums?

As for L-MAN... 5/10. Everything looks too forced.

[TheAmazingOne]

Really slick Tyson Kidd sig; 8.5/10

The E-Fed ones work as a symbol of status fine, but as a true signatire they don't work; 2/10

[Noc]

I know I'm biased, but I'll try to leave out the fact that I made it.

I'd say a 6, maybe 6.5. There's just this one bit that annoys me about it, and it was clearly rushed. I'll be honest, I'm kinda embarrassed by it.

:shrug2:

[TheAmazingOne]

Your Jeff Hardy gets 8 from me, the effect and use of pictures is good, but it's very small. Also, I'm really pleased with the sig you made me, the only thing I would say is it's simple and there is slightly too much shadow on Batista.

If you really are embarrassed then you could make it again (hint hint) but I'm perfectly happy. Just don't feel too harsh on yourself, even a sub-par sig by your standards is awesome.

[JoeyShinobi]

The one that leaped out at me about that sig was the lack of shadow on Batista's left shoulder, but I thought the concept was cool, even if it was simple. Simple's usually the best, anyway.

7/10, in any case.

[Ziggy]

6/10

Very simple =o

[Swanton Bomb]

7/10 - it's simple, but for some reason it looks awesome :p

[Son of Shockey]

6/10. I know what it is, but it looks kinda...meh to me.

[Jar Jar Binks]

5/10 Who the hell are the guys in the sig?

[Romeo]

The greatness that is SHOCKLATE.








You don't know at least one of the guys in the sig? Do you live under a rock, sir?

[Ziggy]

You don't know at least one of the guys in the sig? Do you live under a rock, sir?

That's what I was thinking <.<

7/10 for the Tyson one. Very nice ... moving... effect >.>

4/10 for the Hardy one because Matt Hardy is full of suck.

[airwaves]

8/10

Basic but the text is so well done that it looks great.

[Chewbacca]

9/10

Awesome is all I can say!

[Jar Jar Binks]

6/10 It just isn't that great

[Box Car Rocco]

6/10.

[Irishsara]

7/10 cuz the GIF rocks

[Ziggy]

6/10

Pretty eyes make the sig =O

[Noc]

10/10

I can't fault it, and if there are no faults to be found, no points can be deducted.

[Sean]

10/10.
Do I need a reason?

[LHARR]

6/10

[Romeo]

Holy fuck, Sean, you came out of nowhere!

8/10 for the WM25 one.

[Box Car Rocco]

9/10.

[Sean]

Holy fuck, Sean, you came out of nowhere!


It's what I do. :D

6/10

[Noc]

5/10

You need Nocing up.

:slap:

*No offence to whom made it, as shown, I rate with no bias. Or I try to anyways.

[Thurl]

Sean made his own sig I think...

and 10/10.

You needs to be watching Ro Noc, he is going to be unseating you from your throne as the sig King of LOP soon...

[Romeo]

Sean made his own sig I think...

and 10/10.

You needs to be watching Ro Noc, he is going to be unseating you from your throne as the sig King of LOP soon...

I'm not really out for Noc's blood. Shame on you for making us compete and all that. :D

7/10. I really want to make you a new version of that.

[LHARR]

8/10 thurl

[Irishsara]

6/10

Cool but its too busy ... like too many sigs. pick two ?

[Romeo]

7/10

The look on the photographer's face is made of pure win.

[Jabba The Hut]

8/10

[Bang! Bang!]

7.5/10

[Ziggy]

8/10

Looks very nice.

[Soul]

8/10. Who doesn't love some Ro Magic?

[NightofDay]

8/10. The real Master of the Universe (Sid can move over)

[PopeFred]

15.96/19 = 84%
More Cow Bell.

[Soul]

6/10 Text looks a bit odd and it's sorta plain.

[PopeFred]

9/10
Love the Doctor - can't wait to see the new one...
(Thanks for the feedback on my last sig - it was boring... so I tried again)

[Swanton Bomb]

6/10 - The pictures don't suit it and the red text doesn't go well with the picture borders.

[Chewbacca]

Its amazing.

10/10

[Soul]

9/10

Another MagicPiece

[MissouriDragon]

8/10. I have no idea what it is, but it's very polished.

Every now and then, just to put a smile on his face, I bust out the sig that Noc says is his favorite of all the ones he's made:

http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd205/mahan3000/mutadragon-1.png

Pretty dope, eh? If he ever decides to make any money with this stuff, this should be in his portfolio. Muta, son.

EDIT: That reminds me, I should have him doctor up this Pai Mei pic I've got now...

[Irishsara]

I <3 Muta, it is epic, you hear me epic

Mark/10

[Kano]

The camera guy gets the lol factor from me, so

8/10

[Han Solo]

4/10.

Maybe if it was bigger and I had a bloody clue who it was,

[Chewbacca]

cheap laugh plus my no homo love of you and being rick rolled give this a

9/10

[Ziggy]

8/10

Vury Purty

[Noc]

8/10. I have no idea what it is, but it's very polished.

Every now and then, just to put a smile on his face, I bust out the sig that Noc says is his favorite of all the ones he's made:

http://i224.photobucket.com/albums/dd205/mahan3000/mutadragon-1.png

Pretty dope, eh? If he ever decides to make any money with this stuff, this should be in his portfolio. Muta, son.

EDIT: That reminds me, I should have him doctor up this Pai Mei pic I've got now...

Still my fave, by a long way too. As far as the money part, I've done an MMA promo poster and got some mma gear as payment, the guy likes it so much that he said he'll get the word around and try get me some more to do.

Gotta love that sig...

[PopeFred]

10/10 for the Lord of Sigs...
Alright this is my last attempt for something good.

[Han Solo]

7.5/10 which is pretty good...

[Marvin]

It's quite funny, I suppose. 7/10

[Romeo]

10/10 for the Lord of Sigs...
Alright this is my last attempt for something good.

2/10. It's too big and I can hardly see what you were trying to mask with the text.

Kafu's gets a 6/10 for getting a mild chuckle from me.

marvin's gets a 7/10 for having good colors, but otherwise a meh one.

[Swanton Bomb]

I'll give that one a 10/10, but without the tagline it'd be a 9.

[PopeFred]

9/10 and with out the taglines it's 10/10
The sig is amazingly awesome - the rest is just bragging.
People will awesome sigs like that have no need to brag about anything.

[Jar Jar Binks]

6/10

[LHARR]

7.5/10

[Jar Jar Binks]

Wm 25: 6/10

hbk: 7/10

[Ziggy]

9/10 and with out the taglines it's 10/10
The sig is amazingly awesome - the rest is just bragging.
People will awesome sigs like that have no need to brag about anything.

Like mine =D

L-man - Same rating as before =o

[Jar Jar Binks]

Ziggy- same as before also

[Soul]

8/10 - Because I love anything involving Hulk Hogan getting kicked in the face. Oh, and it's a good sig too.

[Swanton Bomb]

^ 9/10. If it wasn't for the white background (it might not show up on evrybody's computer), then it'd be a 10.

[Jar Jar Binks]

10/10 frieken awsome

[Romeo]

^ 9/10. If it wasn't for the white background (it might not show up on evrybody's computer), then it'd be a 10.

You're using Internet Explorer, aren't you?

[Swanton Bomb]

Yep.

[Cereal]

9/10 I like the jeff hardy action.


We don't live in igloos


Yes we do, don't listen to him. ;)

[Romeo]

Yep.

Well, go get the new one. It handles PNGs better.

[JoeyShinobi]

Er, I'll rate Cereal Killer's, seeing as Romeo's has been rated 5 or 6 times already.

7/10. It's a bit big, but I kinda like it.

[Jar Jar Binks]

Yes we do, don't listen to him. ;)

Sorry I let the secret out, I have had people aproach me adn ask me though.

[Johnny Boomerang]

I'll rate Joeys... seeing as he was the last to rate someone's

9/10. It looks fantastic, i just don't like to throw out perfect scores

[Ziggy]

8/10

Very, very nice.

[Jar Jar Binks]

6/10

[Creeping Death]

I'd give it a 6.5/10

[PopeFred]

Neat Death Graphic... very impressive 14/15 cause 9/10 isn't good enough. My desire for a smidge of color is what hold me back from a perfect score.

[Cereal]

Pope, 7/10

Sorry I let the secret out, I have had people aproach me adn ask me though.

I had people in july asking where they could go skiing in toronto.

[Jar Jar Binks]

Ahahah, whenever someone asks me a stupid question like that I just lie. Like I told one woan that we in fact did live in igloos and the government is trying to hide it. She belived me. Dumb bitch

[Chewbacca]

7/10

very very cheesy :D

[Jar Jar Binks]

Orton: 8/10

[Thurl]

8.5/10

Skaos needs a graphics thread...

[Chewbacca]

I dig it

10/10

Is it cause of Mania? Cause I marked for basic thuganomics.

[Thurl]

Oh, I marked pretty hard for Basic Thuganomics myself..

and... 9/10, Noc isn't showing any rust...

[Romeo]

Oh, I marked pretty hard for Basic Thuganomics myself..

and... 9/10, Noc isn't showing any rust...

Dude, that one's mine. ;)

8/10. Word Life.

[Ziggy]

8/10

I'm not a major fan of Cena's, but he's getting there (to what I consider the peak :p )

Hopefully he'll stay at the "peak" forever, hahahaha, or at least as 'taker or HBK.

!

PS, L-Man, do not post below me! You've already rated Ro's awesome sig enough times x.x

[Ada]

9/10. So simple yet very effective. Took one mark off because of the avatar, the smiley face is tilted in a different direction.

[Soul]

9/10 Would be higher, but it uses Keanu from Constantine, and I hate that movie sooooooo much.

[Creeping Death]

9/10. Still don't know who he is. He almost looks like the one professor from Harry Potter. Same actor?

[PIG-E.]

9/10 That's amazing once you actually look at it

[Ziggy]

7/10...

Upon further inspection, I have changed my mind =D

[Soul]

Creeping Death, no it's not. The actor's name is Paul McGann, he played the Eighth Doctor.

And 8.75/10, gotta love Ro.

[Creeping Death]

Gotcha. And as for the rating, same as before.

[Chewbacca]

6/10

I'm just not TOTALLY feeling it. Your column work is better IMO

[Thurl]

Sweet, I get a redo! I should have known that is a Ro....

Still though, 9/10. Not because Ro sucked on it, but because it is Orton.

[EB4]

8.5. Basic Thuganomics FTW.

[Chewbacca]

9/10

Thats a sick pic of MVP

THURL I HOPE YOU DIE! NO, I HOPE ORTON PUNTS YOU IN THE DOME!

[Vikingsno.1fan]

8.5/10 because the Orton one is really cool

[Cereal]

8/10
I like the million-dollar man.
-------
This is my new one, not sure on it though.

[Irishsara]

5/10

Cant read it, frustrated tried, but good size and neat effects but its all illegable.

[Cereal]

I'll give yours 7/10 cause I do like to see Kurt Angle getting choked out.;)

I'll try mine again, I think it's softer now and easier to read. :)

[Irishsara]

10

Way better

[Vikingsno.1fan]

9/10

[PIG-E.]

Irishsara always has fucking awesome sig's. Everytime I see your sig I just "DAMN THAT'S COOL!" and then save the picture and set it as my wallpaper.

[Kano]

4/10

Personal Reasons Sorry PIG-E

[Jar Jar Binks]

6/10 It's nothing special

[Son of Shockey]

Top: 7/10. Meh.

Bottom: 7/10. Meh, but I like the message. :)

[Box Car Rocco]

7.5/10

We all know Priceless are boring but now rate Mark "Ratings" Henry :D

[Cereal]

8/10

I like blink, and mark henry. :)

[Son of Shockey]

7.5/10. It looks kinda cool.

[Jar Jar Binks]

6.5 don't give 2 shits about baseball and the sig isn't that great

[EB4]

7/10 for first sig.

6/10 for the second. LOL-worthy though.

Rate this one(next poster):

Sorry for the huge delay, but here:

http://i435.photobucket.com/albums/qq75/vcwrestling/rca.png

[Thurl]

10/10.

Ro is really rocking em out lately...

[Vikingsno.1fan]

Johnny Cash earns you a 9/10.

[Power Windows]

9. Great subject matter presentation, uses of green and I like the million dollar belt all blown up and serving as a border.

[PopeFred]

10 - I'm in love with the Swagger

[Box Car Rocco]

8/10.

[Jar Jar Binks]

8/10 Lol worthy also

[Irishsara]

6/10, i dunno i guess it just doesnt jive with me

Also is my Hurricane too big? i was thinking about cutting it down but i just love this picture.

[Thurl]

9/10

If he comes back as the Hurricane cape and all, that will be cool.. And for Size, I think your ok, I don't see any mods coming after you for it or anything..

[Jabba The Hut]

9/10

[Irishsara]

7/10 cuz its a wrestling forum

http://i39.tinypic.com/1111lih.jpg

3 Count

the only time Shannon Moore was cool








This sig or my current one?

[Jar Jar Binks]

3 count one

6/10 it is a picture not a sig

[Irishsara]

well my "pictures" always have links and stuff, so more bells and whistles rule

the link that would have gone with the 3count was either the ladder match with the dragons or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzNvcfmSgDw (I Can't Get You Outta My Heart)

[Johnny Boomerang]

I'd give it about a 9/10.

Because Hurricane awesome, and hurricane trying to chokeslam those two is even more awesome. good times...

[airwaves]

8/10

Design is simple but very well done.

[Han Solo]

8/9

[Lazyking]

bowling yea 8/10

[Ziggy]

8/10

Very nice indeed =D

[The Godfather]

7/10

I always liked that sig

[Han Solo]

8/10... It's pretty good I guess....

[Jar Jar Binks]

10/10, jesus christ that is a masterpiece

[Han Solo]

L-Man, I'll be honest I am not a fan of that sig. HBK/Evan Bourne is nowhere near being a dream match and I'm not that big of a fan of Evan Bourne. He's good, but not great. I would definetely not call him an icon either.

5/10 and that's being generous.

[Chewbacca]

10/10

[Lazyking]

8/10
My new sig RO made for me. i know it probly isn't a dreammatch but imo 2 of my faves

[Jar Jar Binks]

8/10 solid but nothing major

[kaos]

Seems a bit too "cluttered" if you know what I mean. 5/10

[Jabba The Hut]

7/10

[Jason Boy]

8/10What do u think about my sig

[DA I VAN]

Havent read the column so dont know what its about. The Rock eh 7/10

[ca$hmoney]

7/10

[Ziggy]

9/10

Love me some James

[Son of Shockey]

7.75/10

A good, solid, clean sig. Go Ro Go.

[PIG-E.]

6/10 not that funny

[Box Car Rocco]

8/10 - I don't think it's to big and I like that effect.

[PopeFred]

8.5 Cool Sig - but I'm American and have to remove .35 for being a Canadian Signature.

[Valladon]

hmmm 7.5/10

I loved Moby Dick, but...unfortunately, it just doesn't tickle my fancy.

[PopeFred]

7 out of 10...
The red text below is unreadable...
But I'm psyched to meet Dakota.

[Irishsara]

7 out of 10, i dont like the colors, i dont know why, maybe its the shade of grey?

[trajik lastat]

7.1/10
captures the moment, but too recent

[MaQ]

7/10...decent, but cant get into it.

[Thurl]

8.5/10

If it didn't have Edge and Jericho it would be a 10... Ro is indeed the man...

[MaQ]

8/10, like the concept.

I am guessing you dont like edge and Jericho??..lol.

[Jar Jar Binks]

7/10

[PIG-E.]

6/10 super hardcore...

[MaQ]

9/10...I actually like it, you got skills.

[Kano]

7/10

[Andy]

9.5/10

[Jar Jar Binks]

5/10

Sorry homie its nothin special

[Box Car Rocco]

3/10.

[Kano]

LOL at the Bats gif

10/10

[Swanton Bomb]

0/10. Hardy/Orton should be the other way round.

[Jason Boy]

6/10- it looks a litttle off

[kaos]

4/10

Coulda brought me in more, but I guess it's to the point and doesn't scream out I'm attention seeking - click me or else the world will come to an end sorta thing..I guess lol

http://i297.photobucket.com/albums/mm221/Thasikkis/amyrose.jpg

[Noc]

6/10.

I mean I like it, but it takes a little too much space.

[Jason Boy]

new sig what you think

[Jabba The Hut]

7/10

[MaQ]

Nice..very nice..8/10.

[Box Car Rocco]

7.5/10. Good but nothing too special.

[Han Solo]

About 0. Your not Canadian, get that Canadian shit out of your sig now. Don't you remember what that Canadian L-Man said about us?

[Noc]

What do you think?

[kaos]

I like. 8/10

[Ziggy]

7/10

That's her hotness rating. Better then the girl in your last sig.

[Lazyking]

10/10 loce me some KRATOS

[Jabba The Hut]

8/10

[rzrbckmaniac4]

9/10

Awesome

[Andy]

I'll give that an 8/10.

[Shaun]

What do you think of my new sig?

Little big and obnoxious really but probably my fav that i have made for here.

[Lazyking]

its cool you got some odd choices 8/10

[MaQ]

7/10

I like the lines.

[Jabba The Hut]

8/10

[MissouriDragon]

MILLION BILLION STARS for the Falcons one. My Tony Gonzalez jersey will be here next week, to remind the Chiefs fans here that their team is a pathetic joke.

[rzrbckmaniac4]

9/10

[Baba O'Riley]

Erm, I have no idea who the people are being English, but it looks good. 7/10

Ignore the fact Jeff's temporarily gone when you rate mine btw:icon_thumleft:

[Jabba The Hut]

9/10

[Box Car Rocco]

8/10. I like the glow around the players.

7/10 for the fave 5.

[Treisk]

^ I enjoy a good Matt Morgan, 8.5/10.

Decided to get back into making sigs after about two years of, well, not.

http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a81/Treisk/TreiskSig1copy.jpg
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a81/Treisk/TreiskSig2-2copy.jpg
Experimenting with a double-color scheme.
http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a81/Treisk/TreiskSig2copy.jpg

[Ziggy]

1. 7/10

It's coolish, but I don't think Treisk really goes with it.

2. 9/10

I think this one is the best. The shape, the color scheme, and the font just work.

3. 8/10

Same as above, but I don't think a double color scheme is good for that sig.

[Kano]

8/10, it looks cool aye

[Sean]

7.5/10

[MaQ]

8/10

[kaos]

8/10

Creative and nice

[Son of Shockey]

7/10.

Simple but sexy. I have no idea who that is, though.

[Jabba The Hut]

9/10

[MaQ]

9/10 for the first one

8.5/10 for the 2nd one.

[Baba O'Riley]

8/10 for quality of first even if I only like Maria and Velvet

9.75/10 for second. I never got to see the HF but that is all shades of awsomeness!

[Son of Shockey]

Smackdown one: 8.5/10

Soccer one: 7/10. I docked points because I hate soccer. Sue me. :p

[MaQ]

7/10. It so true.

[TJ Tilli]

9/10 for the Divas one. you know i'm helpless when it comes to puppies!

9/10 for the Hart's one as well. it's made by the best there is, the best there was, and the best there ever will be.

[Jabba The Hut]

9/10

[Han Solo]

Incredibly craptacular for the American football one, purely because it is American football, and "its decent" for the one with the guy who's face is blocked, probably AJ Styles, with the Global title.

By the way, my rating scale:

Preserve that shit forever, its solid gold
its very very fucking good
its awesome
its the shit
its good
its okay
its decent
could be better could be worse
could be a lot better, but not the worse I've seen
Seriously, that's your sig
WTF is that supposed to be that's crap
Even crap would say that's crap
Incredibly Craptacular

That's right, a 13 point rating scale

[MaQ]

6/10

Btw, not a bad scale at all.

[TJ Tilli]

mmm alrite.. get rid of Daffney. lol

7/10

[trajik lastat]

just finished

[Irishsara]

7/10 cuz its a hopeless dream and i dig the underdog.

IS this too big?

[PIG-E.]

I don't think so

9/10
People underestimate how cool normal pictures can be as sigs

EDIT: Nobody rate mine, as it's currently not there

[Son of Shockey]

10/10

Greatest sig ever, PIG.

:D

[Box Car Rocco]

9/10, I really like the colours.

I lost my awesome sig that Romeo made me because I'm an idiot.

Is this GIF good?

[Thurl]

BCR, I have no idea what the hell your sig is about so I give it an 8/10.

[Jabba The Hut]

9.5/10

[Baba O'Riley]

8.5/10(Football one)
8/10(Basketball one)

[Mentoch the Mindtaker]

8/10 is a good sig, but points taken off for Swagger having such a smile on ihs face, while the others are so serious. Just kinda takes away from continuity.

[Baba O'Riley]

11/10!

[PIG-E.]

I'm watching the Jersey Shore just for that episode.

[Deathstar Megatron]

9/10. I particularly like the rumble effect on Notorious

[Con Man]

9/10. I particularly like the rumble effect on Notorious

5/10, pretty average.

[Serotonin]

8/10

[MaQ]

9.5/10

[Serotonin]

11/10 lol

[Killswitch]

10/10

[Serotonin]

11/10

[Ziggy]

9/10